More and more couples choose assisted reproduction technology (ART) or surrogacy to realize their dreams of parenthood. These procedures include artificial insemination, using a gestational carrier or both. The process can require vast amounts of time, money, and patience to succeed. The last thing the intended parents expect to hear is that, after all the financial and emotional investments, the parentage of the born child comes into question.
Recently in media, a couple in Greenwich, Conn. filed a law suit against the doctor who helped them with fertility treatment. The case began in 2002 when a woman visited Dr. Ben Ramaley to have an intrauterine insemination performed. The womans husbands sperm sample was supposed to be used and help her get pregnant. Nine month later, the woman gave birth to twin girls. The couple got suspicious right after the babies were born because the babies skin color was way too light coming from a black father.
After several months of speculation and anxiety, the couple took a DNA paternity test and discovered that the father was not the biological father of the twins. The couple filed a suit against the doctor, and one court ruled that the doctor intentionally used his own sperm sample in an extreme and outrageous act.
Further investigation found that the doctors chart recordings were scant in detail, hardly legible and there was no indication who performed the procedure. There was no record that Ramaleys patient had signed an informed consent form, and some of the samples found at his office were not clearly labeled either.
Although this type of incident is not very common, it is important to note that human errors could occur at any fertility clinics, and not every service provider offers the same quality treatment. When there is doubt about maternity and paternity of a child produced with fertility treatment or surrogacy, a simple DNA test can answer the question and bring peace of mind.
Universal Genetics is an AABB accredited DNA testing laboratory that can help in this type of situation. Call us at 1-800-914-1002 to talk to one of our caring DNA consultants or email us at email@example.com if you have questions.